Bamboo toilet roll - which is best?

Bamboo toilet roll comparison - which is best?

Bamboo loo roll seems to be the 'it' product for your bathroom these days, and who can blame you when its so much better for our planet than your classic toilet paper.

Toilet roll is typically made of paper - which obviously comes from trees. According to the Confederation of Paper Industries, the UK uses 1.3m tonnes of tissue a year, with the average British consumer reportedly getting through 127 rolls every year.

The average tree that weighs around 1,000 pounds produces just over 800 rolls of toilet paper. And so ultimately, the average person wipes their behind with about 384 trees within their lifetime in the form of toilet paper. That's a lot of trees!

Deforestation is a huge problem for the planet, especially with the recent fires in the Amazon rainforest and Australia. Last year, the rate of deforestation equalled to a loss of 30 football fields every minute.

So, this is where bamboo comes in. If you want to know more, we produced a blog post last year on bamboo toilet roll and whether it truly is the more environmentally friendly option.

We've put together a comparison of the leading brands when it comes to bamboo toilet roll.

Brand

Shipping + Offsetting

Packaging

Bleached?

Price

Cheeky Panda

Sea Freight / Carbon Balanced with The World Land Trust

Cardboard

100% recyclable

Plastic free

Treated with hydrogen peroxide during manufacture

£36 for 48 rolls (200 sheets)

= 37.5p per 100 sheets

Who Gives a Crap

Sea Freight / Donates 50% of profits to charities like WaterAid

Wrapped individually

Most packaging can be composted

Not plastic free though

Bleached with elemental chlorine

£40 for 48 rolls (370 sheets, 3 ply)

= 22.5p per 100 sheets

GreenCane

Sea Freight / None

Plastic free packaging and cardboard boxBleached, but free from chlorine based chemicals

£28.80 for 48 rolls (300 sheets, 2 ply)

= 20p per 100 sheets

Bumboo

Sea Freight / Plants a tree for every box of rolls purchased

Wrapped individually

All packaging is fully recyclable and compostable.

Plastic free packaging

Bleached, but free from elemental chlorine (ECF)

£40 for 48 extra long rolls (300 sheets, 3 ply)

= 27.8p per 100 sheets

Looking at the above table, Cheeky Panda is by far the most expensive brand, with GreenCane coming in at the cheapest.

All brands use some sort of bleaching for their products. Bleaching is used to make the toilet paper white in colour. However, there is an argument for not using chemicals or bleach, because do we really need our toilet roll to be white in colour when its just going to be flushed away?

All brands use sea freighting to ship their products, and Cheeky Panda and Bumboo both offset their emissions in some way. Who Gives a Crap doesn't offset their emissions, but they do donate half of their profits to a chosen environmental charity. GreenCane doesn't do either, so it doesn't fare as well as the others environmentally.

However, Who Gives a Crap is the only brand that still uses plastic in their packaging. So, not great in terms of the environment. In addition, they individually wrap each roll in paper (along with Bumboo), so potentially using quite excessive packaging. But both Bumboo and Who Gives a Crap use packaging that is compostable, which could make up for the fact they individually wrap their rolls.

Overall, Bumboo seems to be the best option of the above when taking into account price and environmental factors - it's the second cheapest, attempts to offset its carbon emissions, and its packaging is all recyclable and compostable and plastic free.

What do you think of bamboo toilet roll? Do you use it? Let us know in the comments below!

Back to blog

4 Comments

RosPosted on February 14th, 2020 at 11:04

Just coming to the end of a box of Who gives a crap. It’s lasted us a year! Many rolls didn’t tear properly at the perforations and I complained. The response was positive : send the number found on the inside cardboard roll to their customer services and ... but I didn’t bother.
I’ve got on ok with it apart from the raggedy mess I often get when tearing sheets from the roll. I will not be buying it again

Imogen Posted on February 29th, 2020 at 02:37

Yes - but neither of the articles cover one very important aspect!
How does it perform?.... Is it strong enough, soft enough?
Or does it shred and feel thin and non-absorbent?
Have been looking at Cheeky Panda on Ocado's website, but no description there either - so am hesitant to buy a nine-roll pack.

Shahed Ezaydi (Intelligent Hand Dryers)Posted on March 4th, 2020 at 11:48

Thank you both for your comments. We will definitely look into the performance of these brands, and try and produce a future blog post around this topic.

meryl hallPosted on May 30th, 2020 at 12:55

I bought Noo Trees bamboo t.p. online when stores here ran out of t.p. My 1st time using bamboo t.p. it's great - works great, sturdy, feels fine, and in ref. to comment above tears easily at perfs. I just ordered more even tho stores here now have t.p. - much of traditional paper t.p. in U.S. comes from virgin conifers in northern Canada. Bamboo has to be better than that!

Leave a comment